Activism / StudentNation / November 8, 2024

Will More States Try to Protect Marriage Equality With Trump Back in Office?

Voters in California, Colorado, and Hawaii approved ballot proposals in 2024 to protect same-sex marriage rights over fears that the Supreme Court could overturn Obergefell v. Hodges.

Liam Beran

A same-sex marriage supporter waves a Pride flag in front of the US Supreme Court Building.

(Anna Moneymaker / Getty)

From Election Day until 12:30 pm on Wednesday, The Trevor Project, a nonprofit LGBTQ+ youth suicide prevention organization, saw its contact volume for live messaging, text, and crisis hotline services jump 125 percent compared to a normal day. The organization expects it to “potentially only increase,” CEO Jaymes Black told The Nation in a statement, as LGBTQ+ advocates fear that a second Trump term could lead the Supreme Court to overturn Obergefell v. Hodges—which required states to recognize same-sex marriage.

Some states were prepared. On Election Day, voters in California, Colorado, and Hawaii passed ballot proposals aimed at protecting same-sex marriage rights. The amendments ultimately will either prevent the state legislature from enacting any restrictions on same-sex marriage, remove constitutional bans, or specifically enshrine same-sex marriage rights in the state’s Constitution. According to the Movement Advancement Project, 32 states—home to nearly 8.5 million, or 61 percent, of LGBTQ+ adults—now have constitutional amendments or statute bans on same-sex marriage that would take effect if Obergefell were overturned.

“It’s great that we got these wins this week, and we hope additional states will seek the same sort of appeals of discriminatory laws,” Logan Casey, director of policy research for equality-focused think tank the Movement Advancement Project, told The Nation. In a deep-blue state like Oregon, which has a constitutional ban on same-sex marriage, similar amendments to California’s, Hawaii’s or Colorado’s could likely pass. But in a more competitive state—like Wisconsin, for example, where Republicans retained control of both state legislative chambers—such an amendment is a tougher prospect.

Despite Kamala Harris’s loss on Tuesday, the marriage equality amendments passed easily; California’s with 61 percent of the vote, Colorado’s with 63.6 percent, and Hawaii’s with 51 percent. The victory of the amendments alongside Harris’s national loss, according to Don Haider-Markel, a University of Kansas political science professor and expert on public opinion regarding same-sex marriage, showed the electoral weakness and unpopularity of the Biden administration. “If you look at a state like Wisconsin, for example, where Tammy Baldwin ended up in a very close reelection battle, if the numbers are accurate right now, she certainly outran Harris in that state,” Haider-Markel said. “It’s very difficult when the economy, at least, feels bad to people, to outrun that for an incumbent.”

Though the same-sex amendments are replicable, Democratic lawmakers might be unlikely to prioritize social equality over “kitchen-table issues” over the next four years, Haider-Markel said. In his view, the party’s focus caused losses among working-class voters and potential Republican Party gains among non-white men. But around 64 percent of people support same-sex marriage in states where it would be illegal if Obergefell were overturned, according to a March 2024 report from the Public Religion Research Institute. Though conservatives may claim success running on anti-trans policies, Casey says, same-sex marriage’s broad approval throughout the electorate leads him to believe it’s not necessarily fair to “be concerned about a marriage amendment in a solidly blue state.”

Seventeen states allow citizens to directly initiate constitutional amendments—though their requirements vary. Successfully advocating for a same-sex marriage measure’s passage, Haider-Markel said, requires citizen advocates to decide if they wish to spend time and effort on a measure that “may or may not be important down the road,” rather than organizing for candidates who support their viewpoints.

But many of those who could be affected by the overturning of Obergefell say a ballot proposal is a worthy endeavor. Acadia Bradley, a junior at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, found Trump’s win devastating, especially given the hope she had felt for the election over recent weeks. During Trump’s presidency from 2016–20, Bradley felt homophobia was emboldened—as if Trump “almost [gave] them a free pass, or a little bit more courage to act on their hatred towards us.”

Wisconsin is one of 24 states with both statutes and constitutional language prohibiting same-sex marriage. But the state has no citizen initiative mechanism—meaning that to remove the constitutional language, lawmakers would have to propose a constitutional amendment that is then brought to voters. Though Democratic lawmakers have attempted to remove both the state’s constitutional and statutory language bans, state Republican lawmakers have let the proposals stall in legislative committees and derided them as unnecessary. State Assembly Speaker Robin Vos, a Republican, did not respond to a question from The Nation asking if he’d support such proposals in the upcoming legislative session.

Students like Bradley feel that it’s natural to worry about the future, given Trump’s past rhetoric toward LGBTQ+ people, and she wants Wisconsin lawmakers to remove those bans. “I think it should have been done already. But pressure is definitely a little bit more on now.”

We cannot back down

We now confront a second Trump presidency.

There’s not a moment to lose. We must harness our fears, our grief, and yes, our anger, to resist the dangerous policies Donald Trump will unleash on our country. We rededicate ourselves to our role as journalists and writers of principle and conscience.

Today, we also steel ourselves for the fight ahead. It will demand a fearless spirit, an informed mind, wise analysis, and humane resistance. We face the enactment of Project 2025, a far-right supreme court, political authoritarianism, increasing inequality and record homelessness, a looming climate crisis, and conflicts abroad. The Nation will expose and propose, nurture investigative reporting, and stand together as a community to keep hope and possibility alive. The Nation’s work will continue—as it has in good and not-so-good times—to develop alternative ideas and visions, to deepen our mission of truth-telling and deep reporting, and to further solidarity in a nation divided.

Armed with a remarkable 160 years of bold, independent journalism, our mandate today remains the same as when abolitionists first founded The Nation—to uphold the principles of democracy and freedom, serve as a beacon through the darkest days of resistance, and to envision and struggle for a brighter future.

The day is dark, the forces arrayed are tenacious, but as the late Nation editorial board member Toni Morrison wrote “No! This is precisely the time when artists go to work. There is no time for despair, no place for self-pity, no need for silence, no room for fear. We speak, we write, we do language. That is how civilizations heal.”

I urge you to stand with The Nation and donate today.

Onwards,

Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editorial Director and Publisher, The Nation

Liam Beran

Liam Beran is a 2024 Puffin student writing fellow focusing on LGBTQ+ issues for The Nation. He is a journalist and student at University of Wisconsin–Madison.

More from The Nation

Vice President Kamala Harris speaks onstage during a Pride celebration on June 28, 2023, in Washington, DC.

Trans People Shouldn’t Be Scapegoated for Democrats’ Failures Trans People Shouldn’t Be Scapegoated for Democrats’ Failures

Politicians and pundits are stoking a backlash to trans rights in the wake of the election. They’re playing a dangerous game.

Sydney Bauer

Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) is seen at a press conference on upcoming Joint Resolutions of Disapproval (JRD) aimed at blocking certain offensive weapon sales to Israel in Washington, DC, on November 19, 2024.

Bernie Sanders Is Leading a Bold New Effort to Block Arms Sales to Israel Bernie Sanders Is Leading a Bold New Effort to Block Arms Sales to Israel

The senator has more allies than ever in his fight to hold Israel accountable and save lives in Gaza.

John Nichols

President Donald Trump pointing in front of an American flag.

Will “Serious” Republicans Block Any of Trump’s Freak-Show Cabinet Picks? Will “Serious” Republicans Block Any of Trump’s Freak-Show Cabinet Picks?

Will they stand up to even the scariest of these nominees? I’m not optimistic.

Joan Walsh

Kamala Harris, campaigning in Washington, DC, on October 29, 2024, faces protests from hundreds of people expressing disapproval of her administration’s Gaza policy.

Harris’s Gaza Policy Was a Disaster on Every Level Harris’s Gaza Policy Was a Disaster on Every Level

Palestine may not have swung the election one way or another. But Democrats unquestionably paid a high price for their refusal to hold Israel accountable.

Y.L. Al-Sheikh

Former president Donald Trump speaks after being declared the winner of the 2024 presidential election at the Palm Beach County Convention Center in West Palm Beach, Florida, on November 6, 2024.

Donald Trump Has NOT Won a Majority of the Votes Cast for President Donald Trump Has NOT Won a Majority of the Votes Cast for President

Donald Trump’s popular vote total has fallen below 50 percent, and his margin over Kamala Harris has narrowed considerably as all the votes are counted.

John Nichols

Close-up of Gov. Pritzker with his left hand up in a fist.

When Does Power Concede? Thwarting MAGA Will Take More Than Protest and Symbolic Resistance. When Does Power Concede? Thwarting MAGA Will Take More Than Protest and Symbolic Resistance.

If we want to deploy actual power to block Trump’s vicious agenda once he takes control of the federal government, we will have to look to the states.

Van Gosse