Activism / September 11, 2024

Where Is the Outrage Over Israel’s Killing of Aysenur Eygi?

The Biden administration made clear that the murder of an American demands a response—unless that American is killed in the West Bank by the Israel Defense Forces.

Jack Mirkinson

Crowds commemorate Aysenur Ezgi Eygi in Oakland, California, on September 9, 2024, after Israeli soldiers shot her in the head in the West Bank as she was standing in solidarity with the Palestinian people.

(Tayfun Coskun / Anadolu via Getty Images)

In February, after three US troops were killed in a drone strike in Jordan, President Joe Biden issued a warning. “The United States does not seek conflict in the Middle East or anywhere else in the world. But let all those who might seek to do us harm know this: If you harm an American, we will respond.”

The family of Ayşenur Eygi might beg to differ.

Current Issue

Cover of April 2025 Issue

Last week, Eygi, a 26-year-old American citizen, was fatally shot in the head during a demonstration against illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank. Multiple eyewitnesses told reporters that Israeli soldiers assassinated her as she stood in the rear of the protest.

“It was a direct shot to the head, it was not an accident,” one witness told Haaretz. “She was being extra safe out of all of the volunteers, she and her friends were standing the furthest back, in the safest spot that we thought.” Another witness told the paper, “We were visible to the army, just standing around not doing anything. Nothing was happening. I heard two live shots—one hit a metal object and then a Palestinian and injured him in the leg and then one second after I turned and I saw [Eygi] laying unconscious on the ground.”

The murder of an American is no more or less tragic than the murder of any other human being. But American deaths typically receive outsize attention from politicians and the press. In other circumstances, you’d expect the execution of a peaceful American protester to draw outrage from the US president. Yet, as of this writing, Biden has made only the vaguest, factually incoherent comments about Eygi’s killing. Vice President Kamala Harris has said nothing at all. Nor has either of them contacted Eygi’s family. In fact, it took four days for a senior Biden administration official to offer any condemnation of her death.

The United States is not in the habit of allowing other countries to murder its own citizens. But Eygi’s killing appears to have rendered the most powerful country on earth a helpless bystander, willing to outsource its response to Israel.

“Our partners in Israel have indicated that they are conducting a process and that they will make public their findings,” State Department spokesperson Vedant Patel told reporters on Monday, declining to promise that the US would investigate on its own. He also made clear that Israel would get the benefit of the doubt as to what exactly had occurred, despite the fact that Israel has a long history of lying about its soldiers. “Any time an American citizen or civilian loses their life, it is incredibly tragic. But the circumstances around how that happens is important,” he said.

“If you harm an American, we will respond” has morphed into “If you harm an American, we will repeatedly cite another country’s investigation and insinuate that the murder was justified.” The conclusion to draw is clear: The death of an American demands an immediate, forceful response—unless that American is killed by Israelis while protesting on behalf of Palestinian rights.

It’s hardly the first time the United States has engaged in such double standards. In 2022, Israeli snipers assassinated Shireen Abu Akleh, a US citizen working for Al Jazeera in the West Bank, while she was wearing a press vest. Every available piece of evidence suggests that Israeli forces targeted her. The Biden administration essentially ignored her death. No American investigations were launched. Nobody has faced any accountability for the killing. Like Eygi’s, Abu Akleh’s family has never been on the receiving end of one of Biden’s vaunted meditations on grief. Such displays of empathy are apparently reserved only for the right sort of tragedies.

The parallels don’t end there. Back in 2022, Abu Akleh’s relatives were granted a meeting with Secretary of State Antony Blinken—one which they later described as mostly useless. And on Tuesday, Blinken was chosen to respond to Eygi’s death. He was careful to wait until after the Israeli government had released the results of its own supposed inquiry. Israel claimed that that Eygi “was hit indirectly and unintentionally by IDF fire,” and that it had been trying to shoot another protester, who it said had been causing a “riot.”

The Nation Weekly

Fridays. A weekly digest of the best of our coverage.
By signing up, you confirm that you are over the age of 16 and agree to receive occasional promotional offers for programs that support The Nation’s journalism. You may unsubscribe or adjust your preferences at any time. You can read our Privacy Policy here.

Multiple reports have refuted the claim that there was any kind of disturbance taking place when Eygi was killed, and “we were actually trying to shoot a different person in the head” is hardly the most compelling excuse. But it was enough for Blinken.

Speaking at a press conference in London, Blinken called Eygi’s killing “unprovoked and unjustified,” adding, “No one, no one should be shot and killed for attending a protest. No one should have to put their life at risk just to purely express their views. The Israeli security forces need to make some fundamental changes in the way they operate in the West Bank, including changes in their rules of engagement.”

This seems like tough talk until you examine it more closely. Egyi’s death was “unprovoked and unjustified”—but it was also deliberate. Blinken’s refusal to say so meant that, far from demanding real accountability, he wound up endorsing the false narrative that her killing was some awful blunder, not an intentional assassination. And the idea that the Biden administration, which has been bankrolling the genocide in Gaza for nearly a year, is going to do anything to force Israel to make the changes Blinken demanded is fanciful.

Later on Tuesday, Biden was asked about Eygi. His response was even worse. “Apparently it was an accident, ricocheted off the ground and just got hit by accident. I’m working that out now,” he told reporters. It would be hard to imagine a more tone-deaf, checked-out answer.

Ayşenur Eygi was, by all accounts, a dedicated organizer, activist, and scholar. Her first name meant “life and light.” And she spent the last moments of that life trying to help oppressed people. In a better world, she would be exalted by her government. Instead, the United States and Israel have collaborated in a tawdry effort to minimize her death.

Support independent journalism that exposes oligarchs and profiteers


Donald Trump’s cruel and chaotic second term is just getting started. In his first month back in office, Trump and his lackey Elon Musk (or is it the other way around?) have proven that nothing is safe from sacrifice at the altar of unchecked power and riches.

Only robust independent journalism can cut through the noise and offer clear-eyed reporting and analysis based on principle and conscience. That’s what The Nation has done for 160 years and that’s what we’re doing now.

Our independent journalism doesn’t allow injustice to go unnoticed or unchallenged—nor will we abandon hope for a better world. Our writers, editors, and fact-checkers are working relentlessly to keep you informed and empowered when so much of the media fails to do so out of credulity, fear, or fealty.

The Nation has seen unprecedented times before. We draw strength and guidance from our history of principled progressive journalism in times of crisis, and we are committed to continuing this legacy today.

We’re aiming to raise $25,000 during our Spring Fundraising Campaign to ensure that we have the resources to expose the oligarchs and profiteers attempting to loot our republic. Stand for bold independent journalism and donate to support The Nation today.

Onward,

Katrina vanden Heuvel

Editorial Director and Publisher, The Nation

Jack Mirkinson

Jack Mirkinson is a senior editor at The Nation and cofounder of Discourse Blog.

More from The Nation

Twenty-six years ago, the St. Pat's for All parade in Queens, New York, began as a response to the exclusion of Irish LGBTQ communities from the Fifth Avenue parade. Now it welcomes Irish and Irish American solidarity with Palestinians.

There’s Another St. Patrick’s Day Parade in New York—and This One Stands Up to Trump There’s Another St. Patrick’s Day Parade in New York—and This One Stands Up to Trump

The St. Pat’s for All parade started when the more famous Fifth Avenue parade barred queer groups. Twenty-six years later, it welcomes Palestinian solidarity organizations.

Phoebe Grandi

Police officers remove members of Act-Up, who have staged a sit-in inside the hallway of the New York State Capitol in Albany.

We Need to Turn Our Outrage Way Up We Need to Turn Our Outrage Way Up

This is no time to sit idly by. People’s lives are at stake. We have to put our bodies on the line.

Gregg Gonsalves

Columbia University Mahmoud Khalil Protest

Mahmoud Khalil’s Detainment Won’t Stop the Pro-Palestine Student Movement Mahmoud Khalil’s Detainment Won’t Stop the Pro-Palestine Student Movement

The reverberations of Khalil’s arrest are being felt beyond Columbia University’s campus.

StudentNation / Lara-Nour Walton

Mahmoud Khalil, a student negotiator during the protests at Columbia University against the Gaza genocide, speaks to the press on April 29, 2024.

Mahmoud Khalil Is the First Activist to Be Disappeared by Trump Mahmoud Khalil Is the First Activist to Be Disappeared by Trump

The detention and attempted deportation of Khalil is a test by Trump to see how far he can go—and a test for us to see how hard we will fight back.

Laura Jedeed

Students staging a sit-in at Milstein Library on March 5.

Columbia Expelled Student Protesters For the First Time in Over 50 Years. But Activists Won’t Back Down. Columbia Expelled Student Protesters For the First Time in Over 50 Years. But Activists Won’t Back Down.

On March 5, protesters were arrested after dozens formed a sit-in at Milstein Library to demand the reinstatement of three expelled students.

StudentNation / Lara-Nour Walton

CUNY Faculty Are Still Determined to Hire Palestinian Studies Scholars

CUNY Faculty Are Still Determined to Hire Palestinian Studies Scholars CUNY Faculty Are Still Determined to Hire Palestinian Studies Scholars

Faculty at Hunter College submitted a revised job listing after Governor Hochul told the school to remove one that used the terms “settler colonialism,” “genocide,” and “apartheid...

StudentNation / Luca GoldMansour