In recent days, the Democratic presidential campaign has become increasingly fractious. From questions about each other’s “qualifications” for the job to the fierce exchanges during their heated debate in Brooklyn, tension between Clinton and Sanders is on the rise. As comedian Paula Poundstone tweeted, “You’re both qualified. You also both need a nap.” And it’s not just the candidates who need to give it a rest.
It seems like everyone on the left is cranky—and it’s only getting worse. Recent primary wins by Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton’s continuing lead in delegate count mean that the Democratic Primary ain’t over till it’s over on June 25th. That’s nearly 100 days of your Facebook feed filled with people who agree on most issues being totally dismissive and mean to one another. Sure, it’s not as bad as on the other side of the political spectrum, where comparing penis size and spousal hotness has become the norm. But do we really have to accuse one another of lying, cheating, head-in-the-sand stupidity when we more or less want the same things? Universal healthcare, reproductive justice, livable wages, humane immigration policies, and an end to endless war?
The nastiness can get even more personal when you’re a mixed-candidate couple, like we are. We won’t lie to you: We don’t have it all figured out. In fact, we are the kind of couple that can get into a serious argument over things like how to properly make a hard-boiled egg or the best curriculum for a gender studies program. And of course we debate—sometimes vociferously—the merits of our preferred candidates. Yet somehow in this most contentious of election seasons, we have managed to maintain our pro-Bernie/pro-Hillary stances without a single fight. No-one has slept on the couch… yet.
Friends are surprised. Last fall they asked us, “How will you survive the primaries?” And their concern was hardly misplaced. We’ve seen friendships unravel over Facebook posts for or against this or that candidate. But until recently, we were heartened that Hillary and Bernie—like us—acknowledged that they have much more in common than not. They both repeated the truism that the differences between them paled in comparison to the vast chasm between the Democrats and Republicans on just about every issue. Their debates were issue-based, serious, and substantive. They agreed and disagreed, but clearly shared commitments to economic, racial, gender equity. They reminded us that they were united in opposition to the Draconian and xenophobic policies of the Republican candidates.
But as things have taken a nastier turn—with accusations flying and social and traditional media fanning the flames of animosity in the tedious attempt to transform a presidential election into a boxing match—we can’t help wondering if our candidates and the more bellicose and contentious of their supporters might want a bit of advice from a Hillary/Bernie happy homestead. Here are four suggestions for keeping the peace.
As feminist theorists, we have long understood that “othering” is precisely how we enable violence and dehumanization. And as feminist and leftist activists, we have watched in dismay as this othering—and more banal and everyday forms of demonization—have infiltrated the conversation among progressives. The “Bernie or Bust” and “Hillary is the only electable candidate” phenomena are as empty as insisting your partner load the dishwasher correctly or you’re walking out the door. We don’t mean to minimize the differences in policy approaches of the two candidates; we do, however, want to insist that these differences don’t have to turn the other into the enemy or evil incarnate. Because if we progressives decide to break up with one another, our next boyfriend will be Donald Trump or Ted Cruz.
Suzanna Danuta WaltersSuzanna Danuta Walters is a professor of sociology and director of the Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies Program at Northeastern University. She is the editor of the feminist journal Signs and the author of numerous books, most recently The Tolerance Trap: How God, Genes, and Good Intentions are Sabotaging Gay Equality (NYU Press 2014).
Laurie EssigLaurie Essig directs the program in Feminist, Gender & Sexuality Studies at Middlebury College. She is the author of several books including American Plastic: Boob Jobs, Credit Cards and Our Quest for Perfection (Beacon) and is currently writing a book on romance and neoliberal economics.