The wordplay is the definition… literally!
Joshua Kosman and Henri PicciottoIn an &lit clue, the whole clue is the definition, and the whole clue is the wordplay. We follow US tradition and signal such clues with an exclamation point. We have written about these twice: Lit Parade and And the Lits Keep on Coming!.
Sometimes, of course, an exclamation point is just an exclamation point, and it signals nothing else, as in these examples: GASP Cry out, “Gee, a snake!” (4) NOSFERATU Vampire bats: “Fear us not!” (9) PERRY COMO Singer with a pop record initially in Mexico—and how! (5,4) YOSEMITE Hey, a Jew in a national park! (8)
In our puzzles, in perhaps 3/4 of the cases, the exclamation point does indicate an &lit clue. Here are the &lits from our third year as The Nation’s puzzlers: APTEST It might reveal the most qualified! (2,4) CABARET It consists of a bar, etc.! (7) CAPER Prance about without a bit of nervousness! (5) CELL PHONE Individual to hold this when talking! (4,5) DIET PEPSI Deep sip? It is not very healthy! (4,5) EQUALITY Justice’s ultimate character! (8) FIRST Trees’ T! (5) GRAVITY’S RAINBOW Experimental writing? Say “Bravo”! (8,7) HEALTHIER Can make it haler, eh?! (9) HOOFPRINT Thin proof after a stampede! (9) INSOLENCE Silence? No, misbehaving! (9) INSULT It pains, ultimately, inside! (6) ISLE Arrange leis here! (4) MINERAL Aluminum found by one who goes underground, for example! (7) MOONLIGHT Low luminescence, primarily found in darkness! (9) MOSH PIT Most hip dancing?! (4,3) NUMBER ONE I! (6,3) PREDATOR Vicious raptor capturing energy with food, in the end! (8) ROGET Where you find, e.g.: rot, corrupt! (5) ROPER Vaquero, perhaps, at heart! (5)
SEMAPHORE Ultimately, communicate with a visual representation, perhaps
received by shore! (9) SHORELINE Herons lie all over the place! (9) SLANG It’s “in” hipsters’ language! (5)
We believe that the solver’s extra satisfaction from an &lit clue gives the constructor permission to be a little less strict than usual when writing those clues. Thus you might find that one or two of the above definitions is a bit verbose or vague, and the wordplay in one or two clues is perhaps far-fetched or the indicator iffy. Some cryptic hardliners may have a problem with this liberal stance, but hey, we’re liberal.
Other cryptic hardliners object to &lit clues based on initials or last letters, as those are easier to construct: NASH Ogden—a humorous wordsmith, ultimately! (4) WICCA Wherein individual covens could affiliate, primarily! (5) YETI Origins of yarn: “Everest’s terrifying iceman!” (4)
While we admit that these are not as impressive constructions as some others, we like them anyway, because we think they are fun to solve.
One last example—we liked this very concise charade &lit: POETS Bards! (5) But our test solvers felt it was too hard, so we ended up with this one: POETS A couple of bards! (5)
Should we have stuck to our original idea?
This week’s cluing challenge: VERBATIM. To comment (and see other readers’ comments), please click on this post’s title and scroll to the bottom of the resulting screen. And now, four links: • The current puzzle • Our puzzle-solving guidelines | PDF • Our e-books (solve past puzzles on your iOS device—many hints provided by the software!) • A Nation puzzle solver’s blog where every one of our clues is explained in detail. This is also where you can post quibbles, questions, kudos or complaints about the current puzzle, as well as ask for hints.
Joshua Kosman and Henri PicciottoJoshua Kosman and Henri Picciotto are The Nation’s puzzlers. To read more about Kosman, click here. To read more about Picciotto, click here. Kosman and Picciotto explain what they’re up to in “Solving The Nation’s Cryptic Crosswords” (also available as a PDF). Check out The Nation’s Current Issue page each week for the latest puzzle.