Toggle Menu

The I-Don’t-Recall Man

Many of you may not have had the time to tune into the testimony of Attorney General Alberto Gonzales before the Senate Judiciary Committee. So, as a public service, here's just the nub of what you need to know about his morning appearance, as taken down by your trusty scribe. Think of it as a little 3-minute primer for a busy world on the state of (in)Justice (Department of…) in America:

Gonzales' introductory statement: "I shoulda been more precise… My misstatements were my mistakes, no one else's… I have been extremely forthcoming with information… not the actions of someone with something to hide…"

Responses to Committee Chairman Sen. Leahy (D-VT.): "I can only recall… I don't recall… I did not know… it appears… I was not responsible for… I have no recollection… Again, Senator, I was not responsible for compiling that… I don't recall a specific mention… It appears… as I recall… I don't recall Senator Dominici ever…That rationale was not in my mind, as I recall… Senator, that's an answer that I have to get back to you… Senator, I'd like to give you that information, but…"

The Nation

April 19, 2007

Many of you may not have had the time to tune into the testimony of Attorney General Alberto Gonzales before the Senate Judiciary Committee. So, as a public service, here’s just the nub of what you need to know about his morning appearance, as taken down by your trusty scribe. Think of it as a little 3-minute primer for a busy world on the state of (in)Justice (Department of…) in America:

Gonzales’ introductory statement: “I shoulda been more precise… My misstatements were my mistakes, no one else’s… I have been extremely forthcoming with information… not the actions of someone with something to hide…”

Responses to Committee Chairman Sen. Leahy (D-VT.): “I can only recall… I don’t recall… I did not know… it appears… I was not responsible for… I have no recollection… Again, Senator, I was not responsible for compiling that… I don’t recall a specific mention… It appears… as I recall… I don’t recall Senator Dominici ever…That rationale was not in my mind, as I recall… Senator, that’s an answer that I have to get back to you… Senator, I’d like to give you that information, but…”

Responses to Sen. Specter (R-PA.): “Senator, I don’t want to quarrel with you… Based on what I thought, what I understood was going on… I believed that was ongoing… I don’t recall… What I recall is… I don’t recall whether Mr. Mercer presented me the numbers… Senator, I have no recollection about that, but I presume that that is true… Senator, I do recall having a conversation with Mr. Rove… Senator, you’re talking about a series of events that occurred over possibly 700 days… putting it in context, Senator, I would say that my involvement was limited… Senator, of course, in hindsight…”

Reponses to Sen. Kennedy (D-MA.): “I think that’s a fair question, Senator… I was not the person in the Department who had the most information… Since then, I have gone back and looked at the documents available to Congress… I’m not aware that anyone… I believe that I had a good process… Senator, I did not review the document… Senator, I think it’s a good question… I don’t recall in connection to this review process Mr. Sampson was involved in… I don’t recall everyone who was there… Senator, there may have been other discussions…”

Responses to Sen. Brownback (R-KS.): “I do not recall what I knew about… I just don’t recall the reason… It appears there were concerns about… Now, in hindsight… I’m not aware of any new facts here… She’s the other person, quite candidly, Senator, that I don’t recall… I myself was confused, quite frankly, when I testified… Generally, I recall…”

Responses to interjection by Chairman Leahy: “Sir, I don’t recall sending a follow-up quite frankly. I don’t know if it was a mistake or misstatement in my testimony… “

Responses to Sen. Kohl (D-WI.): “Senator, I was never aware… Senator, again, this is a process that was ongoing that I didn’t have transparency into… With all due respect Senator… he’s the person who has the answers… Senator, I’ll go back and see if there is something that I can do… We’ve done great things!…”

Senator Feinstein (D-CA.): “Senator, I don’t recall specifically the genesis of the idea… I don’t have any recollection about the mechanics of the legislative process… As I recall, his updates were brief… as Mr. Sampson gave me updates, I don’t recall… I accept full responsibility… Senator, I don’t recall making the decision that day… I don’t recall exactly when I made the decision… Senator, I don’t recall knowing whether… Senator, I don’t know that…”

The NationTwitterFounded by abolitionists in 1865, The Nation has chronicled the breadth and depth of political and cultural life, from the debut of the telegraph to the rise of Twitter, serving as a critical, independent, and progressive voice in American journalism.


Latest from the nation