(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)
Politics / October 31, 2024

Detroit Is More Than Just a Melting Pot

With a storied legacy of collective organizing, the future of the working class can still be found in the Motor City.

Photos by Alex Webb. Written by Eli Day

As the election draws the country’s attention toward swing states like Michigan, eyes inevitably drift toward Detroit, the state’s population center and one of the Blackest major cities in the country.

We know why. Biden couldn’t have won Michigan in 2020 without carrying metro Detroit. And once the polls closed, Trump’s crusade to bulldoze our democracy rolled through the Motor City before collapsing under a wave of organized opposition from everyday people here. And more recently, both the Democratic Party and Vice President Kamala Harris’s campaign have been haunted by the Biden administration’s sponsorship of Israel’s genocidal war in Gaza and now Lebanon. As Biden and Harris continue to arm the slaughter and refuse to impose any costs on Israel for it, they risk driving Dearborn’s majority-Arab population further away and costing themselves the election in the process.

But this is only one small corner of Detroit’s fluorescent democratic culture. If you only pay attention to voter turnout every four years, then you’re missing all the best stuff—the democracy in our workplaces, neighborhoods, and sprawling grassroots networks.

How We Got Here

Metro Detroit is a mosaic of cultures and traditions. At times, they fold into one another, turning the mosaic into a kaleidoscope.

Like in the reawakening union movement. Or the summer 2020 uprisings following George Floyd’s murder. Or in the furious opposition to our government arming and defending Israel’s evisceration of Gaza.

Before all that though, the city’s early- and mid-20th Century working class only had a few common aspirations working as a bridge between their different worlds.

It’s a well-known story by now. Detroit’s booming automotive industry drew a steady stream of determined immigrants, most of them fleeing poverty or oppression and arriving here with the hope of having a little more say in deciding their destinies.

Eastern, Southern, and Central Europeans. Black Southerners sprinting as far and as fast away from the Jim Crow South as they could. The Latino communities that made Southwest Detroit impossibly rich with life. And our vibrant Arab and South Asian enclaves—families of Chaldean Iraqis, Palestinians, Lebanese, Yemenis, and Bangladeshis spanning Detroit, Dearborn, and Hamtramck.

“Lured by the promise of freedom and opportunity that was denied to them,” Thomas Sugrue writes in The Origin of the Urban Crisis, rivers of immigrants flowed into the Motor City from every corner of the planet.

(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)

What We Built

These new Detroiters were determined to have some control over their lives. So they got involved in the areas where group decisions get made—in their workplaces, neighborhoods, and City Hall. In each case, they faced powerful opponents who saw sharing power with the public as a direct threat to their enormous fortunes.

It’s clear why: Detroit is an overwhelmingly working-class city. Genuine majority rule would likely lead to outcomes that favor the many over the few. Wealthy car companies that made a killing working workers into the ground did not want their input on how to run Ford, GM, or Chrysler. A racist real estate industry that locked Black and brown families into crumbling ghettos was not eager to have its business methods held up to the light. And politicians who let these local oligarchs profit off working families’ pain did not want the public channeling their anger at remaking local government to serve everyday people.

(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)

It didn’t take folks long to realize that their fates were tied together. The labor movement rose on this principle. When Ford finally recognized the UAW in 1941, Black and white workers led the strike that forced them to negotiate. With Detroit as its center of gravity, militant and increasingly diverse unions won real victories for workers on wages, working conditions, and benefits in the decades that followed.

(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)

What We Learned

Like everywhere else, the backlash from Detroit’s corporate class against unions, regulations, taxes, and democratic institutions was swift and ruthless. Groups like the League of Revolutionary Black Workers tried to build an opposition with a fighting chance. But corporations were winning their “one-sided class war,” as UAW president Douglas Fraser put it in 1978, against everyone who wasn’t already wealthy or well-connected.

Once the union movement collapsed, so too did the middle class, as multinational corporations left town to more ruthlessly exploit low-wage workers around the globe. The city’s tax base crumbled as white families flocked to segregated and federally subsidized suburbs. Neighborhood segregation and poverty deepened in Detroit.

The labor movement and civil rights movement were now in shambles. Electoral politics became the last arena for the city’s struggling majority to achieve any type of progress.

Detroiters have enormous democratic imaginations, despite our institutions’ rarely delivering democratic outcomes.

Fortunately, the lessons ricocheting around union halls and communities across the country have also been absorbed here. Without outside movements to pressure and keep politicians up at night, private power beats the common good every time.

(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)

Detroit is one of history’s great battlegrounds for workplace democracy. And now the UAW and other unions are beginning to use their muscle to pick smart fights again and force companies to fairly compensate workers for the wealth they’ve created. And nearly every corner of the city has some grassroots group waging a heroic uphill battle against corporate titans and the political establishment on housing, public schools, transportation, the energy system, Palestinian freedom, and so much more.

(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)
(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)
(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)
(Alex Webb / Magnum Photos)

Can we count on you?

In the coming election, the fate of our democracy and fundamental civil rights are on the ballot. The conservative architects of Project 2025 are scheming to institutionalize Donald Trump’s authoritarian vision across all levels of government if he should win.

We’ve already seen events that fill us with both dread and cautious optimism—throughout it all, The Nation has been a bulwark against misinformation and an advocate for bold, principled perspectives. Our dedicated writers have sat down with Kamala Harris and Bernie Sanders for interviews, unpacked the shallow right-wing populist appeals of J.D. Vance, and debated the pathway for a Democratic victory in November.

Stories like these and the one you just read are vital at this critical juncture in our country’s history. Now more than ever, we need clear-eyed and deeply reported independent journalism to make sense of the headlines and sort fact from fiction. Donate today and join our 160-year legacy of speaking truth to power and uplifting the voices of grassroots advocates.

Throughout 2024 and what is likely the defining election of our lifetimes, we need your support to continue publishing the insightful journalism you rely on.

Thank you,
The Editors of The Nation

Eli Day

Eli Day is a writer from Detroit.

Alex Webb

Alex Webb has been working as a photojournalist since 1974. His experiences in the Caribbean and Mexico in the mid-1970s led him to begin photographing in color, which he continues to do today documenting US cities.

More from The Nation

The Perfect, Smiling Wives of the Christian Right

The Perfect, Smiling Wives of the Christian Right The Perfect, Smiling Wives of the Christian Right

Far from being an immutable fact of Christianity, evangelical antifeminism is recent, virulent, and gaining traction every day.

Feature / Talia Lavin

A depiction of the Broadway Linear Park from 32nd Street in Manhattan.

Can New York’s Most Famous Street be Turned into a Park? Can New York’s Most Famous Street be Turned into a Park?

The effort to transform Broadway into a pedestrian space.

Books & the Arts / Karrie Jacobs

Gisele Pelicot

Abusers Aren’t Always Powerful Men. Some of Them Are Regular Guys. Abusers Aren’t Always Powerful Men. Some of Them Are Regular Guys.

Even in an age when feminist rhetoric is familiar, 
violence against women is all too common.

Column / Katha Pollitt

Jeff Bezos attends the UFC 306 at Riyadh Season Noche UFC event at Sphere on September 14, 2024, in Las Vegas, Nevada.

Newspapers That Refuse to Endorse Are Betraying Journalism—and Democracy Newspapers That Refuse to Endorse Are Betraying Journalism—and Democracy

Billionaire publishers who censor endorsements that offend Donald Trump confirm their scorching disregard for the traditions of a free press.

John Nichols

This Anti-Immigrant Ruling by a Trump Judge Tells You All You Need to Know

This Anti-Immigrant Ruling by a Trump Judge Tells You All You Need to Know This Anti-Immigrant Ruling by a Trump Judge Tells You All You Need to Know

For judges like Trevor McFadden, the cruelty toward immigrants is not only the point, it’s the source of the pleasure.

Column / Elie Mystal

How Wisconsin Lost Control of the Strange Disease Killing Its Deer

How Wisconsin Lost Control of the Strange Disease Killing Its Deer How Wisconsin Lost Control of the Strange Disease Killing Its Deer

Despite early containment efforts, chronic wasting disease has been allowed to run rampant in the state. That’s bad news for all of us.

Feature / Jimmy Tobias