April 10, 2024

Extra! Extra! Steve Brodner’s Brilliance Recognized by Herblock Prize

Brodner, a frequent contributor to The Nation, is both a great caricaturist and a great portraitist.

Jeet Heer
Steve Brodner, Under Trump’s Comb-Over (2015).

Steve Brodner’s love of cartooning almost got him kicked out of college. Raised by a working-class single mother in Brooklyn, he started selling cartoons when he was in high school to make a little extra spending money. His first, a cartoon about local Brooklyn politics, ran in The Kings Courier, a local newspaper, in November 1971. He enrolled in Cooper Union to study fine art, but cartooning remained his ambition, particularly after he encountered the work of Thomas Nast, the 19th-century master of cross-hatching who famously helped end the reign of the corrupt Tweed gang that ruled New York politics.

“Nast was the big atom bomb in my early career,” Brodner told The Comics Journal in 2004. “Nast showed you could change the world with pictures.” Already radicalized by the civil rights movement and the Vietnam War, Brodner was well set for a career as an incendiary illustrator.

But the fine-arts ethos of Cooper Union wasn’t prepared to nurture a cartoonist. “It is not always easy to be a political person at art school,” Brodner recalls. “I draw with an eye towards what’s interesting to me, which is what is grotesque, bizarre, and strange.” Brodner ran into trouble in a class taught by “a very traditional academic artist who was a brilliant draftsman but who couldn’t tolerate what I was doing.”

Brodner’s clash with this teacher got so bad that the dean began to suggest that the young rebel should go elsewhere. Fortunately, at age 19, Brodner won a national cartooning contest, beating out a field of contenders that included the iconic New Yorker artist Charles Addams (creator of the Addams Family).

Brodner, of course, went on to become famous as a caricaturist, and this year he was awarded a much-deserved Herblock Prize worth $20,000.

Cooper Union’s mistake had been in thinking there was a dichotomy between cartooning and fine art—between being a caricaturist and a portraitist.

The secret of Brodner’s art is that he recognizes no such division. A successful caricature combines a plausible likeness of the subject’s visage with some element of fantasy or exaggeration that brings out the inner life. Brodner learned to unleash his wild imagination not just from Nast but also from more recent masters such as Ralph Steadman (whose hallucinatory visions rivaled those of his collaborator Hunter S. Thompson) and David Levine (whose elegant caricatures defined The New York Review of Books for decades). As with his influences, Brodner’s wildest flights of fantasy are undergirded by a portraitist’s sense of composition and attention to telling detail.

Brodner’s caricatures are so boldly grotesque, so willing to stretch familiar visages into the most unlikely silly putty, that it might seem odd to praise them for their subtlety. But consider Under Trump’s Comb-Over (2015). The caricaturist’s touches are immediately legible to the viewer: the absurd hair; the aggressive eyebrows; the beady, scrunched-up eyes. But live with the drawing for a bit and you notice how Brodner has captured Trump’s very peculiar fishy mouth, a pinched little orifice. This is both a likeness and something more, with the super-reality of the best caricatures.

Jeet Heer

Jeet Heer is a national affairs correspondent for The Nation and host of the weekly Nation podcast, The Time of Monsters. He also pens the monthly column “Morbid Symptoms.” The author of In Love with Art: Francoise Mouly’s Adventures in Comics with Art Spiegelman (2013) and Sweet Lechery: Reviews, Essays and Profiles (2014), Heer has written for numerous publications, including The New Yorker, The Paris Review, Virginia Quarterly Review, The American Prospect, The GuardianThe New Republic, and The Boston Globe.

More from The Nation

Billie Allen, an artist and writer who has maintained his innocence since being sentenced to death in a sham trial more than 25 years ago.

An Appeal to President Biden: Pardon Billie Allen An Appeal to President Biden: Pardon Billie Allen

Biden’s decision to commute Allen’s death sentence deserves praise and gratitude, but the president should go even further—and free an innocent man.

Yusef Salaam

Jimmy Carter addresses the nation.

A Tale of Two Presidents A Tale of Two Presidents

Remembering Carter as we steel ourselves for Trump’s second inauguration.

D.D. Guttenplan

The Mountain West’s Mega-McMansion Problem

The Mountain West’s Mega-McMansion Problem The Mountain West’s Mega-McMansion Problem

The rich have turned the region into “ultra-exclusive enclaves,” creating hazardous living conditions for everyone else.

Feature / Sasha Abramsky

Kamala Harris Was Poised to Crush the Women’s Vote. What Went Wrong?

Kamala Harris Was Poised to Crush the Women’s Vote. What Went Wrong? Kamala Harris Was Poised to Crush the Women’s Vote. What Went Wrong?

Once Harris became the nominee, women voters surged behind her. But on Election Day, she won a smaller share of them than Biden did. This is how it fell apart.

Feature / Joan Walsh

An activist holds a placard that says “I Stand with Planned Parenthood” during a rally in Los Angeles on May 21, 2019.

Blocking Planned Parenthood From Medicaid Will Only Worsen the US Maternal Health Crisis Blocking Planned Parenthood From Medicaid Will Only Worsen the US Maternal Health Crisis

The “defund Planned Parenthood” campaign is back—and headed to the US Supreme Court.

Rachel Rebouché

Jeff Bezos, owner of “The Washington Post” (left); Donald Trump.

The Media Is Giving Away Its Rights Even Before Trump Tries to Take Them The Media Is Giving Away Its Rights Even Before Trump Tries to Take Them

Recent events have shown that Trump does not have to impose a new regime of censorship if the press censors itself first.

Column / Elie Mystal