World / September 17, 2024

Israel Has Bombed Gaza’s Healthcare System Back to the 19th Century

Gaza’s doctors are frequently working in conditions not seen since before the Civil War.

Abdullah Shihipar
L: Palestinian doctors work on a patient following the Israeli attack on Nuseirat Refugee Camp in Gaza on September 13, 2024. R: Surgeons prepare to amputate a patient's leg at Gettsyburg in 1863.

(L) Palestinian doctors work on a patient following the Israeli attack on Nuseirat Refugee Camp in Gaza on September 13, 2024. (R) Surgeons prepare to amputate a patient’s leg at Gettsyburg in 1863.

(Hassan Jedi / Anadolu via Getty Images; SSPL / Getty Images)

A week after the Gaza genocide began, I was on an airplane watching the 1989 Academy Award–winning film Glory, which tells the story of the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment, an all-Black regiment of soldiers who fought in the Civil War. About 10 minutes into the film, there is a scene where Captain Robert Shaw (played by Matthew Broderick) watches in agony as a soldier endures a painful operation in another corner of the room. That depiction of what battlefield medicine must have been like in the mid-1800s has stayed with me, as I have heard horror stories of what practicing medicine is like in Gaza.

For nearly a year, we have heard from doctors who have described the scenes in Gaza as by far the worst they have ever seen. Many recount unthinkable injuries on children; wounds caused by a sniper; missing limbs torn apart by air strikes. Because of the Israeli blockade of Gaza, doctors do not have the equipment to properly dress wounds or to alleviate people’s pain with anesthesia and painkillers. Antibiotics are scarce and there is little to no clean water. Diseases like Hepatitis A and now polio are spreading rapidly—with one child already paralyzed from the latter, prompting an urgent vaccination campaign from the WHO. The population continues to face conditions of famine. According to the Gaza Health Ministry, more than 40,000 people have died. The Lancet estimates that should the assault continue, the total death toll could end up being as high as 186,000 people.

From the beginning, many—including the head of the World Health Organization—warned about the dire health consequences Palestinians would face if this brutality were allowed to continue. This situation was predictable in part because we know from prior conflicts how disease can take advantage of these conditions and spread. And that brings me back to the Civil War.

At the time of the war, scientists were still learning about what caused disease; Louis Pasteur had only conducted his experiments studying the growth of microorganisms in the 1850s, and germ theory would continue to be developed by Robert Koch well into the 1880s. Knowledge of the importance of sanitation and infection control was similarly limited. As a result, about two-thirds of all deaths in the war were attributable to diseases, including typhoid, malaria, and dysentery.

Despite this, the Civil War did bring about improvements in medicine. The first ambulance systems in the United States grew out of the need to transport people from the battlefield to field hospitals during the war. Systems of triage were used to ensure that the people who needed treatment the most urgently received it. Crucially, people received anesthesia (usually chloroform) when undergoing an operation—and it soon became standard practice in American medicine. Only about 254 of 80,000 operations during the war were performed without it. The sounds of agony that were featured in the film Glory were probably not heard on the operating table that often. Soldiers also had access to painkillers like morphine, although this would lead some to become addicted.

The Civil War began more than 160 years ago, so why make this comparison? The simple answer is that many of the conditions in Gaza are similar to the ones found in the 1860s. In fact, the situation in Gaza is worse in some ways than in the Civil War, because medicine has come so far since then.

While the Civil War saw many deaths from disease, this was in part due to a lack of knowledge. Medicine had simply not progressed enough to be able to respond to the needs of the soldiers. Today, there are no such barriers standing in the way of Palestinian doctors. They have the expertise and the skills to save lives. But Israel has deliberately targeted Gaza’s medical infrastructure and prevented vital equipment from entering the war zone. The spread of disease, death, and famine is the direct result of these choices.

Israel has quite literally plunged Gaza into a pre–Civil War medical context. Doctors at Gettysburg and Antietam had anesthesia and painkillers to give to their patients, while some Palestinian children have found themselves undergoing amputations with no anesthesia. During the Civil War, the majority of deaths were attributable to combatants. In Gaza, civilians make up a large proportion of the dead: killed by a sniper’s bullet while evacuating, eviscerated in an air strike, or dying of disease and starvation in a tent.

The Civil War saw improvements in battlefield medicine that would end up advancing the field of medicine as a whole and benefiting countless people. We have made strides in technological and scientific advancements since then that should make many of those deaths a thing of the past. But while we have advanced in those fields, the past 11 months have shown that we have severely regressed in our morality and humanity. World leaders have demonstrated that you can deny lifesaving medicines and equipment in service of the goal of annihilating a people and do so with impunity. What use is our collective knowledge and advancement in scientific and medical technology, if we allow for a world where people are denied access to basic, lifesaving care—where 19th-century medical conditions are allowed to persist because of a 21st-century commitment to cruelty? Progress in such a world is meaningless; for the sake of humanity, this must stop now.

Support independent journalism that exposes oligarchs and profiteers


Donald Trump’s cruel and chaotic second term is just getting started. In his first month back in office, Trump and his lackey Elon Musk (or is it the other way around?) have proven that nothing is safe from sacrifice at the altar of unchecked power and riches.

Only robust independent journalism can cut through the noise and offer clear-eyed reporting and analysis based on principle and conscience. That’s what The Nation has done for 160 years and that’s what we’re doing now.

Our independent journalism doesn’t allow injustice to go unnoticed or unchallenged—nor will we abandon hope for a better world. Our writers, editors, and fact-checkers are working relentlessly to keep you informed and empowered when so much of the media fails to do so out of credulity, fear, or fealty.

The Nation has seen unprecedented times before. We draw strength and guidance from our history of principled progressive journalism in times of crisis, and we are committed to continuing this legacy today.

We’re aiming to raise $25,000 during our Spring Fundraising Campaign to ensure that we have the resources to expose the oligarchs and profiteers attempting to loot our republic. Stand for bold independent journalism and donate to support The Nation today.

Onward,

Katrina vanden Heuvel

Editorial Director and Publisher, The Nation

Abdullah Shihipar

Abdullah Shihipar is a writer who focuses on public health, race, class, and other social justice issues. He leads Narrative Projects & Policy Impact Initiatives at the People, Place & Health Collective at Brown University.

More from The Nation

Andrée Blouin’s Revolutionary Lives

Andrée Blouin’s Revolutionary Lives Andrée Blouin’s Revolutionary Lives

The African political leader’s autobiography, My Country, Africa, also offers a larger story of empire, oppression, and resistance on the continent.

Books & the Arts / Bill Fletcher Jr.

People gather against a backdrop of unlit buildings in Havana, as Cuba’s national power grid has effectively collapsed.

Life in Cuba Under Sanctions Life in Cuba Under Sanctions

Ordinary Cubans are trapped in a vicious circle of government mismanagement exacerbated by the US embargo.

Feature / David Montgomery

Going for Green: Uruguay’s Renewable Energy Revolution

Going for Green: Uruguay’s Renewable Energy Revolution Going for Green: Uruguay’s Renewable Energy Revolution

With no fossil fuel reserves to rely on and domestic demand rising, the country had to get creative—or go broke just trying to keep the lights on. Here’s how they did it.

Feature / Natasha Hakimi Zapata

La France Insoumise party leader Jean-Luc Melenchon (L) and Parti Socialiste first secretary Olivier Faure address supporters during a campaign meeting in Caen, France, on June 8, 2022.

The Crisis Engulfing the French Left The Crisis Engulfing the French Left

The New Popular Front alliance looked like the best hope the left had against Macron and Le Pen. But after months of internal conflicts, it’s on the brink of collapse.

Cole Stangler

Antony Blinken, Joe Biden, and Lloyd Austin provided Israel with military, diplomatic, and public support knowing that such support would facilitate attacks on civilians, mass murder, and the deliberate deprivation of items needed for Palestinians in Gaza to survive, argues Sarah Leah Whitson.

Why We Asked the ICC to Investigate Biden for Aiding and Abetting Genocide Why We Asked the ICC to Investigate Biden for Aiding and Abetting Genocide

The evidence that Joe Biden, Antony Blinken, and Lloyd Austin helped Israel commit war crimes is overwhelming.

Sarah Leah Whitson

A woman visits a memorial for fallen soldiers at at Kyiv’s Maidan, or Independence Square, on Saturday, March 1.

“We’re On Our Own”: Ukrainians Confront a New Reality “We’re On Our Own”: Ukrainians Confront a New Reality

Even leftists who disagree with some of Zelensky’s policies are glad he didn’t back down to Trump.

Jared Goyette